Skip to main content
Robban Assafina
Columbia shipmanagement — AdvertisementBureau veritas- Leaderboard banner — AdvertisementDNV Leaderboard — Advertisement
Shipping

Improving CII Accuracy

Shipping Groups Push for Revised IMO Carbon Ratings

Posted on:

Updated on:

Shipping Groups Push for Revised IMO Carbon Ratings
Share

BIMCO and major shipping organizations are calling for changes to IMO carbon intensity ratings to better reflect vessel efficiency and reduce distortions caused by port operations.

In a proposal submitted to the International Maritime Organization’s (IMO) Marine Environment Protection Committee (MEPC 85), scheduled for November 30 to December 3, 2026, BIMCO and six other co-sponsors are seeking a reassessment of the Carbon Intensity Indicator (CII) framework, focusing on fuel consumption while vessels are under way.

The submission, jointly sponsored by the Bahamas, Liberia, BIMCO, the International Chamber of Shipping (ICS), INTERTANKO, INTERCARGO and the International Bunker Industry Association (IBIA), argues that the current calculation can produce ratings that do not accurately reflect a ship’s operational efficiency.

Why current CII ratings may be misleading

Under the existing framework, a vessel’s annual CII calculation includes fuel consumed both at sea and during periods when it is not under way, including port stays and time spent at anchor. However, the calculation also depends on the distance traveled, meaning fuel consumed without corresponding voyage distance can negatively affect a ship’s rating.

According to BIMCO, this creates inconsistencies between ships operating under different conditions. Short-sea vessels generally make more port calls than ships on long-distance routes, while congestion and terminal delays can increase fuel consumption independently of a vessel’s efficiency at sea.

Consequently, ships with comparable technical and operational performance may receive different CII ratings because of their trading patterns and port conditions.

The concern is significant because CII ratings form part of the IMO’s mandatory energy efficiency requirements, with vessels assigned grades from A to E. Ships rated D for three consecutive years or E in a single year must develop a corrective action plan to improve their performance.

What changes are being proposed?

The proposal calls on the IMO to use more detailed fuel consumption data collected through its Data Collection System (DCS) to reassess and recalibrate CII reference lines.

The revised reporting requirements, mandatory since January 1, 2026, distinguish between fuel consumed while ships are under way and fuel consumed during other operations. Data covering 2026 will be submitted to the IMO in 2027.

The co-sponsors recommend that the assessment should:

  • Evaluate changes in calculated CII values across different ship types and sizes.
  • Examine how revised calculations would affect the distribution of A-to-E ratings.
  • Review existing correction factors and voyage adjustments, including those relating to port operations.
  • Identify possible market distortions or unequal treatment between comparable ships.
  • Ensure any changes remain transparent, verifiable and do not increase administrative burdens.

Importantly, the submission recognizes that simply removing fuel consumed while vessels are not under way would not be sufficient. Existing reference lines were developed using total reported fuel consumption and would therefore need recalibration to ensure consistent comparisons.

Port emissions remain part of the equation

Although the proposed approach would focus CII calculations on consumption while vessels are under way, it would not eliminate reporting of fuel consumption or emissions during port stays and anchorage periods.

These would continue to be captured through the IMO DCS. The proposal also emphasizes the importance of cooperation between ships, ports, terminals and other transport-chain participants to reduce unnecessary waiting times and improve port call efficiency.

Measures such as just-in-time arrivals and better coordination of berth availability could support emissions reductions while addressing operational inefficiencies that individual ships cannot resolve independently.

Nevertheless, limiting CII calculations to fuel consumed under way would raise questions about how the regulatory framework maintains incentives to reduce emissions during port operations. The distinction between measuring vessel efficiency and accounting for total emissions remains central to the discussion.

What happens next?

MEPC 85 will consider the submission as part of the ongoing second phase of the IMO’s review of short-term greenhouse gas reduction measures.

The IMO has already recognized the need to examine alternative CII metrics, including the possibility of focusing calculations on fuel consumption while vessels are under way.

The review is expected to conclude at MEPC 87 in spring 2028. For now, the existing CII calculation remains unchanged, while the proposal seeks a more data-driven approach to determining whether and how the framework should be revised.

Robban Assafina is now on WhatsApp channel. Click Here

Also ReadIssue 103Issue 103 (July/ Sep. 2026)